Budget rumours key reason for weak growth, says former Bank chief economist


Speculation over the upcoming Budget is partly to blame for weaker-than-expected economic growth figures as worries over tax hikes hit business and consumer spending, the former top economist at the Bank of England has warned.

Andy Haldane, who was chief economist at the Bank until 2021, told Sky Newsโ€™s Mornings With Ridge And Frost that the build-up ahead of the November 26 Budget has been a โ€œcircusโ€ and called for the process to be overhauled to prevent leaks that can damage the economy.

It follows official figures last week that revealed economic growth slowed to 0.1% in the third quarter, down from 0.3% in the previous three months and worse than most economists predicted.

Chancellor Rachel Reeves blamed the weaker performance on the Jaguar Land Rover production shutdown in the wake of its cyber attack, with gross domestic product (GDP) declining by 0.1% during September after the fallout hit activity in the manufacturing sector.

But Mr Haldane said the Budget rumours had โ€œwithout any shadow of a doubtโ€ had a direct impact on growth.

He told Sky News the upcoming Budget has been a โ€œreal circus thatโ€™s been in town for months and months nowโ€.

He said: โ€œItโ€™s caused businesses and consumers to hunker down.

โ€œOne of the reasons we had a very weak growth number last week is because thereโ€™s that Budget speculationโ€ฆ (itโ€™s) dampened peopleโ€™s willingness to spend.

โ€œAnd first and foremost, we need to stop that speculation.โ€

He added: โ€œIf you speak to businesses, speak to consumers, their fearfulness about where the axe will fall is causing them, not unreasonably, to save rather than spend, to not put their balance sheet to work.

โ€œAnd that has taken the legs from beneath growth in the economy.โ€

He urged the Treasury to โ€œdecisively to end that speculation, that pernicious speculation that is dampening growthโ€.

Mr Haldane said: โ€œWe have this pretty much daily speculation about the next tax rise.

โ€œAnd we need to re-engineer that process to either make it watertight, like the Bank of Englandโ€™s monetary policy decisions, or a genuinely open consultation.

โ€œRight now, we have this halfway house of leaks and speculation which serves absolutely no one. Least of all the economy.โ€

On her performance so far, Mr Haldane said Ms Reeves has been dealt a โ€œbad hand, played, in truth, pretty poorlyโ€.

The Treasury has been approached for comment.

Leave comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *.