Put simply, he did it with 25,000 votes. That’s roughly the number of people who voted for him in the Makerfield by-election in June 2026. No wonder Burnham was described as a messiah without a mandate. Starmer, by contrast, won 9.7million votes at the general election two years earlier. Starmer was hopeless. He isn’t missed. But it puts Burnham in an awkward position, particularly since his victory was helped by a very clear pledge to Makerfield voters, designed to soothe their concerns about a specific issue and encourage them to vote for him. Which he then broke.

In his bid for power, Burnham did what politicians seeking power do: he told his audience exactly what they wanted to hear. Makerfield voted 65% for Brexit, so Burnham knew what he had to say. His words look more jaw-dropping by the day. “My view is that Brexit has been damaging, but I also believe the last thing we should do right now is re-run those arguments.โ€ He added: “I am not proposing that the UK considers rejoining the EU.โ€ The PM didn’t stop there.

Burnham added: โ€I respect the decision that was made at the referendum and it is going to undermine everything I have said about strengthening democracy if we don’t respect that vote.โ€ Those were his exact words. He quickly found new ones. At Labour conference in September, he brazenly announced that Brexit had done more harm than good and pledged to set out the options for Britain’s long-term relationship with the EU.

When the BBC challenged him over whether he was reopening the divisive argument about rejoining, he insisted: “No, I’m not proposing that, am I?” He was merely looking at the options. Which could include a customs union, the single market or, as he himself put it, going “all the way”.

That sounds a lot like re-running the argument to me. Heโ€™s also called for a โ€œresetโ€ and advocated taking it “one step at a timeโ€. We can see exactly where he wants those steps to take us. Straight back to Brussels. Despite clearly signalling to Makerfield voters that he wouldn’t.

Labour’s 2024 manifesto explicitly ruled out returning to the single market, customs union or freedom of movement. Burnham is now floating all three.

If Burnham wants to reverse Brexit, let him say so plainly and put it to the country in the next election. Don’t dress it up as a harmless reset or claim it’s “win-win” without even debating it. And don’t pretend that nobody is proposing rejoining when he’s the one putting it on the table. The cost is going to be terrifying, but Burnham won’t tell you that either.

In Makerfield, Burnham didnโ€™t give voters the full picture. That now looks like a deliberate strategy by our fork-tongued PM. If thatโ€™s not โ€œunderminingโ€ democracy, I donโ€™t know what is.