Judge keeps Kilmar Abrego Garcia in jail over concerns ICE will deport him immediately after release
Kilmar Abrego Garcia will remain in jail for now after fears that Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents will swoop to deport him as soon as he is released.
Abrego Garciaโs attorneys expressed concern that his release would lead to immediate detention by ICE and deportation.
A federal judge ruled that the Salvadoran father, who was criminally accused of human smuggling, has a right to be released and even set specific conditions.
But he will remain in jail for at least a few more days while attorneys spar over whether prosecutors can prevent Abrego Garcia’s deportation if he is released to await trial.
Magistrate Judge Barbara Holmes in Nashville on Wednesday rejected federal prosecutorsโ request to imprison the wrongfully deported Salvadoran father while he is awaiting trial on criminal charges.
He can be released on his own recognizance but must attend anger management counseling, home detention, location monitoring and drug testing, the judge said previously.
But President Donald Trumpโs administration has suggested that immigration officials would deport him as soon as he is released.
Three months after he was arrested and wrongfully deported to a brutal Salvadoran prison, Abrego Garicia, 29, was abruptly returned to the United States to face a federal criminal indictment.
He has pleaded not guilty.
Federal judges and a unanimous Supreme Court had ordered the Trump administration to โfacilitateโ his return after government lawyers admitted he was removed from the country due to an โadministrative error.โ
But the government spent weeks battling court orders while officials publicly said he would never step foot in the U.S.
Last week, Holmes denied the Justice Departmentโs motion to keep Abrego Garcia in pretrial detention, noting the โmultiple layers of hearsayโ in government arguments that โdefied common sense.โ
Holmes conceded, however, that Abrego Garcia was likely to end up back in federal custody with Immigration and Customs Enforcement while his criminal case moves through the courts.
Federal prosecutors and Attorney General Pam Bondi have sought to portray Abrego Garcia as a public menace and threat to society; a motion to keep him imprisoned as his case moves to trial accuses him of a range of crimes for which he has not been charged, including โsolicitation of child pornography.โ
Judge Holmes cast doubt on prosecutorsโ arguments, noting that they have been filtered through โat least three, if not four or more, levels of hearsayโ and carried โno weightโ legally.
โThat the level of hearsay cannot even be determined renders the evidence patently unreliable,โ she wrote.
The Associated Press contributed reporting
