Peace deal is no block to Britain leaving ECHR, new report says | Politics | News


Britain quitting the ECHR would not breach the historic Good Friday Agreement, a new report claims. It says claims that the UK cannot withdraw from the European Convention on Human Rights because of commitments made in the peace deal are โ€œentirely groundlessโ€.

One of the authors of the paper from the Policy Exchange said public debate about human rights law reform has been โ€œdistortedโ€ by the repeated assertion that withdrawal from the ECHR would breach the historic agreement.

The 1998 Good Friday (Belfast) Agreement largely ended decades of violence in Northern Ireland and led to the establishment of the powersharing Stormont Assembly.

It was backed by referendums on both sides of the Irish border.

Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch has ordered a review into whether the UK should quit the ECHR, while Reform UK leader Nigel Farage has long supported leaving it.

In a speech last week to launch his partyโ€™s plans to tackle illegal migration, Mr Farage said the Good Friday Agreement could be โ€œrenegotiatedโ€ to remove references to the convention.

His comments were criticised by some politicians in Northern Ireland who argued the ECHR underpins the agreement.

But the Policy Exchange report said โ€œnothing in the UKโ€™s commitments to the peace process in Northern Ireland requires it to remain a part of the ECHRโ€.

It adds that โ€œit is clear that the Belfast Agreement does not forbid the UK (or Ireland) from exercising its right in international law to withdraw from the ECHR.โ€

The report continues: โ€œWhatever the merits of UK withdrawal from the ECHR, nothing in the Belfast Agreement rules it out as a viable course of action.โ€

One of the authors of the paper, Professor Richard Ekins, said: โ€œNeither the letter nor the spirit of the Belfast Agreement in any way requires the UK โ€“ or Ireland โ€“ to remain within the ECHR.โ€

The document has received the endorsement of former Labour home secretary and foreign secretary Jack Straw.

He said: โ€œI am not persuaded that the UK needs to withdraw from the ECHR the better to deal with the unacceptable number of unlawful and unfounded asylum seekers.

โ€œRather, I believe that we should de-couple our own human rights legislation from the convention (as other European countries have done).

โ€œBut the debate about our future relationship with the ECHR and its parent body, the Council of Europe, should be conducted on its merits.โ€

Downing Street has previously ruled out leaving the ECHR, with Sir Keir Starmerโ€™s spokesman saying: โ€œThe ECHR underpins key international agreements, trade, security and migration and the Good Friday Agreement.โ€

Leave comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *.